| Season | Champion | Silver Trophy (2nd Place) | Bronze Trophy (3rd Place) | Picker of the Year | Most 10+ Weeks Picker of the Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Rod Hines Sam Cammarata | Zanshiro Kim | |||
| 2018 | Rod Hines Sam Cammarata | David Hobbs | |||
| 2017 | David Hobbs | Rod Hines | Zanshiro Kim | ||
| 2016 | Bobby Russ | Rod Hines | Jim Svitak | Jesus Silva | |
| 2015 | Sam Cammarata | Jim Svitak | Rod Hines | Sam Cammarata | |
| 2014 | Jim Svitak | Bobby Russ | Dennis McKeown | ||
| 2013 | Greg Lee | Dennis McKeown | Rod Hines | Greg Lee | |
| 2012 | Sam Cammarata | Rod Hines | Dennis McKeown | Sam Cammarata | Sam Cammarata |
| 2011 | Rod Hines | Greg Lee | Hollis Morrow | Rod Hines | Rod Hines |
| 2008 | Teresa Sutherland | Jon Westrick | Tyrone Davis | Teresa Sutherland | Hollis Morrow Teresa Sutherland Jon Westrick |
| 2007 | David Hobbs | David Hobbs | David Hobbs | ||
| 2006 | Greg Lee | Greg Lee | Greg Lee Teresa Sutherland Chris Westrick | ||
| 2005 | Jon Westrick | Jon Westrick | Fred Gregio Jon Westrick | ||
| 2004 | Pete Drummond | Jon Westrick | Pete Drummond | ||
| 2003 | Teresa Sutherland | Pete Drummond | Teresa Sutherland | ||
| 2002 | Teresa Sutherland | Bobby Russ | Jim Svitak | ||
| 2001 | Teresa Sutherland | ||||
| 2000 | Jon Westrick | ||||
| 1999 | Jon Westrick |